UAE bank to pay Dh9.5 million to a customer after sim card swap scam

A UAE-based bank will have to pay Dh9.5 million to a customer who was cheated out of his money in a SIM card swap scam, the Dubai Court of Cassation ruled.

A UAE-based bank will have to pay Dh9.5 million to a customer who was cheated out of his money in a SIM card swap scam, the Dubai Court of Cassation ruled.

In February, the verdict overlooked an initial judgment by the Dubai Commercial Court of First Instance in May 2021, which discovered the bank and a local telecommunication company together and collectively responsible for the fraud.

Advertisement

In April 2015, the victim of the scam (a customer of the bank), whose personal details were not disclosed, gave his brother a power of attorney to manage all bank payments on his behalf.

In October 2018, the customer’s brother got to know that Dh9.5 million were transferred from the account within the last 32 days between August and September of 2018. The customer nor his brother were being informed of these payments. 

Ghassan El Daye, Partner and Head of Litigation Middle East at Charles Russell Speechlys, who represented the telecommunications service provider, “The payment was taken out on 49 different transactions using the phone banking app and digital services, leaving only Dh36 in the bank account.”

The customer further noticed that his mobile phone service was also suspended during the same month. 

After that, the investigations indicated that fraudsters had presented a replacement SIM card request to the telecommunication company of the victim’s mobile number that was recorded with the bank.

The final judgement found the bank guilty after the communication service provider demanded the initial ruling.

Advertisement

In the telecommunication company’s defence, El Daye mentioned Article 284 of the UAE Federal Civil Transactions Code to persuade the court to accept that the telecommunications company was not responsible for the scam by swapping the sim card. 

If any fault happens, the labiality of the bank from where the money was robbed replaces the liability of the telecommunication service provider.

According to Article 284, if the damage is both immediate and consequential, the rules connecting to direct harm shall apply.

In its verdict, the Court of Cassation said the transactions would not have occurred if the client’s personal details were not leaked.

“Being under the golden category which deals with accounts with big sums of money, the customer’s account should have been inactive after no payments were made on it for 28 consecutive months,” the ruling read.

The final ruling also said the bank was liable for the customer’s economic loss after it failed to use a robust authentication system.

SIM swap fraud:- 

It is a type of an account takeover in which fraudsters collect personal details to get a new SIM card administered in the customer’s name.

The scammer will get all the personal data they require, including OTPs, to conduct fraudulent dealings from the customer’s bank accounts using the SIM card.

Tariq Saeed

Read More

UAE confirms 284 fresh COVID infections

A total of 298,820 additional tests for COVID-19 were conducted in the last 24 hours in the United Arab Emirates, of which these new cases resulted positive for the virus.  

Zero Gravity is indicated using a Turtle by SpaceX’s Crew-3

The "turtle-takeover" of space has started. A SpaceX Crew-3 astronaut, Kayla Barron, released a shimmering sea turtle to float over her head shortly after...

5.6kg cocaine discovered from lady traveller at Dubai International Airport

The authorities of Customs' inspection staff has held a woman of Latin American nationality, as they seized cocaine of 5.6kg from the lady passenger, at Dubai International Airport.

Recent

UAE reports 1,388 new COVID-19 cases on Thursday

The United Arab Emirates reported 1,388 new coronavirus cases on Thursday, July 21, after 287,895 PCR tests were conducted.

UN discussions on ‘killer robots’ fail to reach an agreement.

Following objections from manufacturing states, UN talks on autonomous weapons systems, sometimes known as "killer robots," fell short of beginning negotiations into an international...

2024-25 Budget of Dominica will be more people-friendly: PM Skerrit

Roosevelt Skerrit, the Prime Minister of Dominica  vowed to present a more public-centred budget for 2024-25 during a monthly press conference.
admin